A Reason to Kiss the Sea: Montauk Pearl Oysters

VideoBy Liza de Guia on Aug 5, 2012
Post to TwitterPost to FacebookPost to DiggPost to StumbleUponPost to DeliciousPost to Reddit

“I’m a dreamer. I’ve always been a dreamer, and I like to dream. And this company, which we’ve started on a dream, is going to continue on a dreamy kind of path. It’s heaven. This is heaven.”

Meet Mike & Mike. Mike Martinsen and Mike Doall, the founders of Montauk Shellfish Company, a commercial fisherman and marine biologist who’ve teamed up to give back to their community and pay respect to the Earth by launching Montauk’s very first oyster farm: Montauk Pearls.

Montauk Pearls are new to the oyster scene, and the success of their operation has given the East End a new found interest in aquaculture. The two Mikes started their surface grow out system in 2009, leasing out a very unique and hard-to-come-by plot of private land in Lake Montauk.  A plot of land that just-so-happened to be underwater.   As the story goes, Mike M happened to be living on the property and asked his landlord if he could use it for farming.  Luckily, his landlord said yes.

“It just seems like things all just lined up, almost like fate.” – Mike Martinsen

Feedback has been so positive that demand for the “pearls” has already exceeded supply. Five-star chefs in New York and Long Island are featuring their oysters on menus, as are select seafood joints, like Maison Premiere in Brooklyn and The Lobster Place in Chelsea Market.  According to Mike D, “once you open one up, they basically sell themselves.”

And it’s true. I was sold from the first super briny slurp: a snappy crispness to the meat (and there’s a lot of it), and a finish that tasted of slightly-sweet, fresh watermelon rind. Really, it’s Mike M’s surf-related description that makes me smile most:

“It reminds me of being out in the ocean at sunset…a double-overhead swell, perfect off-shore winds, a little rainbow blowing off the back of the wave. It’s like that salt taste of the mist when you’re coming down a wave in through a barrel. It’s that sea taste: misty, salty, ocean bliss”. You really can’t say it better than that!

Enjoy their beautiful story, shot just a few weeks ago. And thanks for watching and supporting food. curated.! It’s been a slow start for me in 2012, but good things are happening again and, thankfully, I’m back on track. Happy slurping!


  1. Jannie says:

    Love the video! I now have an intense craving to try some of the oysters.

  2. Judi Scavuzzo says:

    Amazing … Wonderful to see your video … George and I just loved it … need to visit and try some “pearls” for our self …

    Take care … and Much Love

    Aunt Judi

    • Liza de Guia says:

      Yes you need to visit! It’s great to see in person. If you go, there’s this place called Rick’s Crabby Cowboy Cafe that sits in front of the oyster operation. That’s where you can definitely score some Montauk Pearl oysters!

  3. michele says:

    This is lovely! I grew up in a clam-digging town, so this conjures up loads of nostalgia!

    • Liza de Guia says:

      Thanks for stopping by Michele! It was so beautiful that day, made you understand why some people prefer the sea over office jobs. I hope you try their oysters!

  4. Matt says:

    This is a great video. I really enjoyed it. I grew up in small fishing town and you did a great job capturing that small-town family feel (for lack of a better term). Looking forward to the next video.

  5. John says:

    Great video, Liza — you captured their unique endeavor incredibly well (plus the score complimented it rather nicely, too). I enjoyed them at Clam Bar in Amagansett yesterday and can testify that they, in fact, exceed expectations. Keep up the great work, Mike & Mike!

  6. speaker says:

    JMJ – Inspirational Author, Motivational Speaker

Leave a Reply